Konstantin Nikolaev, the oligarch who helped finance Ms. Butina, has been an investor in projects linked to the Russian government.
 |
| © Dmitry Dukhanin/Kommersant/Sipa USA, via Associated Press Images A cache of hacked emails has shed light on the Russian security connections of the oligarch Konstantin Nikolaev. |
By MIKE McINTIRE, The New York Times
An oligarch who helped finance a Russian gun rights activist accused of infiltrating American conservative circles has been a discreet source of funds for business ventures useful to the Russian military and security services, according to documents and interviews.
The oligarch, Konstantin Nikolaev, emerged in July as the enigmatic backer of Maria Butina, the activist charged with conspiring to use the National Rifle Association to cultivate Republicans in the United States. Mr. Nikolaev has acknowledged underwriting her gun rights advocacy in the past, but denies any involvement in a Russian influence operation and says his only dealings with his government are limited to routine business needs.
[Read a special report on Russia’s 2016 election plot.]
Though his public persona is that of a billionaire in the prosaic industries of ports and railways, a cache of 9,000 hacked emails — from the account of Alexey Beseda, whose father is a general in Russia’s Federal Security Service, the successor to the K.G.B. — reveals another side to his business activities.
Mr. Nikolaev has been an investor in a gun company run by his wife that developed a sniper rifle used by the Russian National Guard, which reports directly to President Vladimir V. Putin. He is also a major investor in a satellite imagery firm that has a license from the Federal Security Service, or F.S.B., to handle classified information.
Less well known is Mr. Nikolaev’s role providing money for a Kremlin-backed project to develop night-vision technology that the military sought after Western sanctions made it difficult to obtain. Mr. Nikolaev’s role was obscured by complex transactions involving offshore companies and Mr. Beseda, the documents show.
The emails described the project as “one of several priority lines of development” approved by Mr. Putin, saying it would counter an advantage enjoyed by “the troops of our probable enemy — NATO.”
“The project closes one of the main strategic technological gaps in the defense capability and technological independence of the Russian Federation,” Dmitry Rogozin, then deputy prime minister, said in a 2013 letter.
A spokesman for Mr. Nikolaev did not deny the billionaire’s role in the night-vision enterprise, but downplayed its significance, saying he “once invested in a private-sector defense technology project, but it went nowhere and he ended his involvement with it in 2015.”
“More to the point, Mr. Nikolaev is not connected to Russia’s security services,” said the spokesman, Jeffrey H. Birnbaum.
Mr. Nikolaev, 47, maintains a low profile in the Russian oligarchy, but he was thrown into the spotlight when his name surfaced in connection with the Butina case.
Federal prosecutors say that Ms. Butina, 29, conspired with a Russian government official and an American political operative to seek back channels between Moscow and Republicans, including members of the Trump campaign, who were sympathetic to improving relations with Russia. In court filings, the Federal Bureau of Investigation said her activities were part of an influence operation, citing her “connection to suspected Russian intelligence operatives.”
The F.B.I. also said that Ms. Butina’s emails and text messages referred to an oligarch with “deep ties to the Russian presidential administration” who served as her “funder.” The oligarch was not named in court documents, but the description matches Mr. Nikolaev, and several people familiar with the case have confirmed his role.
Worth slightly more than $1 billion, Mr. Nikolaev, together with two partners, owns about a third of Globaltrans, one of Russia’s largest rail car operators, and the trio recently sold a major stake in a port business. He also sits on the board of American Ethane, a Houston-based energy company, and has invested in business ventures with Igor Rotenberg, the son of Arkady Rotenberg, a close childhood friend of Mr. Putin’s.
Mr. Nikolaev’s role in the Butina case has been perplexing, in part because prosecutors have offered few details about his interactions with her and his possible motives. Not everyone is convinced that he was a Kremlin functionary. The Bell, an independent website run by Russian journalists, concluded that “Nikolaev is a major businessman with powerful partners who are close to the Kremlin” but “doesn’t resemble the kind of person Russian authorities would select to act as their intermediary.”
Mr. Nikolaev once served on a government-sponsored council for public-private partnerships in the military-industrial sector, along with influential oligarchs like Oleg V. Deripaska, a longtime associate of the Trump campaign’s convicted former chairman, Paul J. Manafort. And his business entanglements stretch into areas that share a theme of military and security applications, which generally require trusted relations with the authorities.
“Nikolaev’s holdings in Russia’s critical infrastructure and weapons programs are sufficient to support the theory that he is an oligarch in good standing with the Russian government and, clearly, with the F.S.B. through his business dealings with Beseda,” said Jeffrey Carr, an American cybersecurity analyst who obtained Mr. Beseda’s emails from pro-Ukrainian hackers several years ago.
Mr. Carr shared the emails with The Intercept in 2015, and more recently with The New York Times.
Mr. Beseda was a hacking target because of his connection to the F.S.B., where his father, Sergey Beseda, was involved in the intervention in Ukraine and is under American sanctions. In a 2015 report, Mr. Carr’s consulting firm at the time, Taia Global, concluded that the younger Mr. Beseda was also “almost certainly an F.S.B. officer,” as was another person involved in the night-vision project.
Mr. Beseda did not respond to requests for comment. Previously, he has not denied the authenticity of the emails.
Publicly, the night-vision project appeared to focus on civilian applications like detecting gas leaks at construction sites and heat loss in commercial buildings. But an 83-page business plan from June 2013, marked “strictly confidential,” made clear that a major objective was to provide the military with up-to-date equipment and help the Russian arms industry “reinforce their position on the world market.”
The business plan described Mr. Nikolaev as a private “co-investor” who would put up roughly $12 million. Other funds would come from a government research institute and a large state-owned development bank.
The plan did not explain that Mr. Nikolaev’s investment would filter through offshore companies registered in the British Virgin Islands, Cyprus and Seychelles. Those firms entered into transactions with other offshore shells involving Mr. Beseda, who took over Mr. Nikolaev’s stake by 2016, according to the Russian newspaper Novaya Gazeta.
The emails also shed light on another of Mr. Nikolaev’s ventures, one that intersected with Ms. Butina’s efforts to cultivate the N.R.A. In December 2015, she accompanied an N.R.A. delegation that included its former president, David Keene, on a visit to Orsis, a Russian gun maker that sells sniper rifles to the Russian National Guard.
There they met Svetlana Nikolaeva, Mr. Nikolaev’s wife, who is the head of Orsis’s parent company, Promtechnologies Group. The 2013 business plan for the night-vision project stated that Mr. Nikolaev “controls the Promtechnologies Group who owns Orsis brand,” and that Promtechnologies “is ready to buy significant amounts of the project products.”
At various times, Promtechnologies executives have included Alexander Beseda, another son of the F.S.B. general, and Alexey Rogozin, the son of the former deputy prime minister. The elder Mr. Rogozin, who is subject to Western sanctions, also met with the N.R.A. group during its trip to Moscow with Ms. Butina.
Mr. Nikolaev’s spokesman said that the billionaire’s involvement in the company ended in 2014, and that it was “a free-standing commercial business unconnected to the Russian government.” He added that Alexander Beseda and Alexey Rogozin worked there “only briefly” and left in 2012.
The Beseda emails also contained documents pertaining to ScanEx, a Russian satellite-monitoring service in which Mr. Nikolaev became a major investor in 2014, along with Mr. Rotenberg, the son of Mr. Putin’s friend. Mr. Beseda appeared to be advising ScanEx on potential contracts with the Russian government, including the F.S.B. and the G.R.U., a Russian intelligence agency.
A letter written in Mr. Nikolaev’s name cited ScanEx’s government clients, saying the firm had a license from “the F.S.B. for carrying out works related to the use of information classified as state secret.” The spokesman said such licenses were “standard” for businesses that gathered “geographical data for commercial use.”
“It is not an indication of a tie to Russia’s security services,” he said.
COMMENTS